Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Laparoscopic append icectomyInterest and enthusiasm shown by general surgeons for therapeutic laparoscopy is rapidly becoming a global phenomenon.The speed of adoption and popularity of laparoscopic cholecystectomy is without precedent in modern surgical history, despite the relative lack of information concerning its morbidity, cost-effectiveness and long-term consequence^'-^, and the fact that some surgeons advocate a more cautious approach4.Although laparoscopic appendicectomy was reported 4 years before laparoscopic cholecy~tectomy~, it has not had such a meteoric rise and is practised routinely in only a few centre^^-^.Why should one bother to remove the appendix laparoscopically when most surgeons claim that they can perform appendicectomy through a small cosmetic incision with minimal complications and a short hospital stay l o ?Unfortunately the facts are somewhat different.Not infrequently, difficulties are encountered which require enlargement of the incision, and even then the ability to evaluate the entire abdomen in a patient found to have a normal appendix is limited.Wound infection rates of 4-7 per cent are still reported following appendicectomy despite the use of prophylactic antibiotics".Furthermore, in a review of over 100oO patients, postoperative pelvic abscesses were shown to complicate the procedure in 3.5 per cent of cases".Other problems relate to the formation of adhesions which may be a source of persistent pain or late bowel obstruction, infertility in women, and to the incidence of incisional hernia and the increased chance of developing a right inguinal hernia.A recent survey of over 2000 patients undergoing emergency appendicectomy in the south-west Thames region showed that the average hospital stay was 4.6 days.Evidence that laparoscopic surgery provides a better approach is still very limited, but four large series have now reported it to be a safe p r ~c e d u r e ~-~.Early experience suggests that patients have improved cosmesis, a decrease in morbidity, a reduction in wound pain, a shortened hospital stay, and a quicker return to normal life.There is also some evidence that the development of adhesions may be reduced13.These findings accord entirely with our own experience of more than 30 cases.Laparoscopy allows both an excellent exposure of the appendix, regardless of its position, and a thorough examination of the rest of the abdomen.It is already an established tool as an aid to diagnosis in young women with abdominal pain and may shorten delay in treatment.Wound infection should be significantly decreased if the appendix is inserted into a bag before its removal; the theoretical risk of increased intra-abdominal abscess formation related to abdominal insufflation has not been s ~b s t a n t i a t e d ~~~.Another consideration is the possible decreased risk of transmission of human immunodeficiency (and other) viruses due to the reduced contact with blood.Evisceration, herniation and small bowel obstruction can largely be avoided by checking all cannula sites before removal of the laparoscope and taking care in closing the rectus sheath.Two of the major criticisms of laparoscopic appendicectomy are that it takes longer to perform than the open procedure and that there is a need to purchase and maintain sophisticated electronic instrumentation.We agree that in the learning phase the former is true, although with experience laparoscopic appendicectomy need take only 15-20mins39.We also agree with Holohan' that there will always be surgeons operating without adequate laparoscopic training and, more importantly, without the judgement to appreciate this lack of knowledge.This is a sad fact of life but it should not be allowed to hinder the development of new 'patient-friendly' techniques.We believe it is essential that an experienced and skilled laparoscopist should directly assist junior surgical staff until they are competent to operate on their own.In this context it is ironic that most surgeons start therapeutic laparoscopy by learning laparoscopic cholecystectomy although appendicectomy is both easier and safer.The latter procedure should allow our future generation of surgeons to be properly trained in laparoscopic techniques.The problem of equipment will soon be irrelevant as the instrumentation will become generally available in line with the increasing range of procedures performed.The development of new technology may make laparoscopic appendicectomy quicker and safer.Already there are instruments
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
R. S. Taylor (1992) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: