Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This exploratory essay examines how asymmetric power may govern the conditions of value creation, the circulation and return of value, and participants' capacity to revise governing arrangements. Building on Eglash and colleagues' work on generative justice and engaging research on structural power, capabilities, and institutional persistence, it proposes a conditional, pathway-specific mechanism: a rule may erode a participant's capacity for continued generation; that erosion may subsequently diminish the participant's effective ability to inspect, contest, exit, or redesign the rule. The two causal links require distinct evidence, and their conjunction neither demonstrates equilibrium nor establishes injustice by itself. The essay distinguishes persistence from strategic equilibrium and dynamical stability, and examines countercases involving beneficial concentration, restored capacities without institutional change, and cooperation sustained by safeguards despite distrust. It also connects value return to warranted trust and prospective responsibility without equating unequal exposure with equal suffering. A multiscale discussion considers how aggregate continuity may conceal locally significant losses and how normative judgments depend on representational choices. The question Do All Beings Suffer? therefore expresses an open ethical inquiry into unequal benefits, harms, and obligations within interconnected relations. The proposed contribution is a diagnostic synthesis and research programme; it makes no claim to a validated model of international equilibrium or to empirical verification of the mechanism.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wanhong HUANG (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: