Key result
Cylindrical catheter tips generate ~4-fold larger lesion volumes than spherical tips at low contact force.
Why the study?
The role of catheter electrode tip shape in the safety and efficacy of cardiac radiofrequency ablation had been overlooked despite observed clinical and experimental differences.
Does a cylindrical electrode tip shape compared to a spherical tip shape alter lesion dimensions and steam pop risk across varying contact forces and powers in a computational model of cardiac radiofrequency ablation?
Does a cylindrical electrode tip shape compared to a spherical tip shape alter lesion dimensions and steam pop risk across varying contact forces and powers in a computational model of cardiac radiofrequency ablation?
This computational modeling study demonstrates that RF catheter electrode tip geometry strongly governs tissue contact area, lesion size, and steam pop risk, with cylindrical tips behaving more predictably across varying contact forces and spherical tips requiring both power and contact force titration.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cylindrical tips may enable consistent low-force ablation in models; leaves open human translation and safety.
Background: The role of catheter tip shape on the safety and efficacy of radiofrequency (RF) ablation has been overlooked, although differences have been observed in clinical and research fields. Objective: The purpose of this study was to analyze the role of electrode tip shape in RF ablation using a computational model. Methods: We simulated 108 RF ablations through a realistic 3-dimensional computational model considering 2 clinically used, open-irrigated catheters (spherical and cylindrical tip), varying contact force (CF), blood flow, and irrigation. Lesions are defined by the 50°C isotherm contour and evaluated by means of width, depth, depth at maximum width, and volume. Ablations are deemed as safe, critical (tissue temperature >90°C), and pop (tissue temperature >100°C). Results: Tissue-electrode contact is less for the spherical tip at low CF but the relationship is inverted at high CF. At low CF, the cylindrical tip generates deeper and wider lesions and a 4-fold larger volume. With increasing CF, the lesions generated by the spherical tip become comparable to those generated by the cylindrical tip. The 2 tips feature different safety profiles: CF and power are the main determinants of pops for the spherical tip; power is the main factor for the cylindrical tip; and CF has a marginal effect. The cylindrical tip is more prone to pop generation at higher powers. Saline irrigation and blood flow effect do not depend on tip shape. Conclusion: Tip shape determines the performance of ablation catheters and has a major impact on their safety profile. The cylindrical tip shows more predictable behavior in a wide range of CF values.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Petras et al. (2022) studied Cardiac radiofrequency ablation (in silico porcine heart model) (n=108). Cylindrical-tip open-irrigated RF ablation catheter (7F, 2.33-mm diameter, 3.5-mm length, 6 irrigation pores) vs. Spherical (hemispherical)-tip open-irrigated RF ablation catheter (7F, 2.33-mm diameter, 3.5-mm length, 6 irrigation pores) under identical protocol settings was evaluated on Lesion dimensions (depth, width, depth at maximum width, volume defined by 50°C isotherm) and thermal safety profile (safe <90°C, critical 90-100°C, steam pop 100°C). Cylindrical catheter tips generated 4-fold larger lesion volumes than spherical tips at low contact force and showed less contact-force dependency.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: