Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Biogenic carbon capture, utilization, and storage (bio-CCUS) is technically feasible and strategically important for climate policy, yet deployment remains largely pre-commercial. While individual bio-CCUS technologies are increasingly well understood, the actor-level dynamics and governance conditions determining value chain formation are less studied. We address that gap through semi-structured interviews with representatives of 13 companies across bio-CCUS value chains and four forerunner municipalities in Finland, characterizing the decision-making environment facing both groups, complemented by an analysis of EU-level and national regulation. The findings reveal that investment in bio-CCUS is primarily constrained by system-level coordination failures: a chicken-and-egg dynamic persists between CO₂ producers waiting for stable demand and users waiting for reliable supply, while missing logistics infrastructure, spatial dependencies, and regulatory fragmentation across legal domains compound the challenge. Biogenic CO₂ is currently largely excluded from EU ETS compliance incentives, and strong policy support for RFNBOs contrasts with the near-absence of comparable incentives for other CCU applications. National policy instruments translate EU frameworks into concrete incentives, but their design may reinforce a focus on fuel-based pathways and limit participation of smaller actors. Municipalities can facilitate local value chain development through land-use zoning, and through linking actors, but cannot substitute for missing market-level incentives. We interpret these findings through the lens of coordination failure, organizing them around four interacting mechanisms – demand formation, complementary investment, infrastructure coordination, and multilevel intermediation – that jointly determine whether investment proceeds. Economic viability of bio-CCUS emerges as a systemic outcome that no single actor can bring about alone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Assmuth et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: