Key result
Rose angina questionnaire shows poor diagnostic accuracy of ~59% for detecting CAD vs treadmill testing.
Why the study?
The validity of the complete and shortened WHO Rose angina questionnaires (RAQ and SRAQ) to detect coronary heart disease (CHD) in a tertiary care hospital setting required evaluation.
Do the complete and shortened WHO Rose angina questionnaires accurately detect coronary heart disease compared to an exercise treadmill test in Indian patients presenting with chest pain?
Observational (n=239)
No
Do the complete and shortened WHO Rose angina questionnaires accurately detect coronary heart disease compared to an exercise treadmill test in Indian patients presenting with chest pain?
Both the complete and shortened WHO Rose angina questionnaires demonstrate poor overall diagnostic accuracy (~57-59%) against exercise treadmill testing in Indian patients, indicating that reliance on these questionnaires in epidemiological surveys may misestimate the true burden of coronary heart disease in India.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cautions against reliance on Rose questionnaires for CHD detection in Indian surveys; leaves open validation of accurate low-cost alternatives.
OBJECTIVES: Validation of the complete and shortened RAQ to detect coronary heart disease (CHD) in a tertiary care hospital. METHODS: In this prospective observational study, 239 patients aged 40-75 years with chest pain, referred for TMT from the cardiology OPD were subjected to RAQ and SRAQ, followed by a treadmill test (TMT). We used the treadmill test with the Bruce/modified Bruce protocol as the gold standard to assess RAQ and SRAQ. RESULTS: The RAQ had 44.3 % sensitivity, 72.6 % specificity, 59 % accuracy, 60 %, and 58.4 % positive and negative predictive values, 1.62, 0.77 positive and negative likelihood ratios, respectively. SRAQ had 87.8 % sensitivity, 27.4 % specificity, 56.5 % accuracy, 52.9 % and 70.8 % positive and negative predictive values, 1.21 and 0.44 positive, and negative likelihood ratios, respectively, to detect CHD. The sensitivity of RAQ and SRAQ was higher in women. CONCLUSION: Both RAQ and SRAQ have poor accuracy in diagnosing CHD in the Indian population. Alternate tools are needed for determining the population burden of CHD in India.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vijay et al. (2025) conducted an observational in Suspected coronary heart disease (chest pain) (n=239). WHO Rose Angina Questionnaire (RAQ) and Shortened Rose Angina Questionnaire (SRAQ) vs. Exercise treadmill test (TMT) using the Bruce/modified Bruce protocol (gold standard) was evaluated on Diagnostic accuracy for detecting coronary heart disease (compared with TMT gold standard) (95% CI 52-65). The WHO Rose angina questionnaire and its shortened version demonstrated poor diagnostic accuracy of 59% and 56.5%, respectively, for detecting coronary heart disease compared with treadmill testing.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: