Key result
Heart rate variability had a small, heterogeneous evidence base across 37 studies (n=5,195), with only 1 study directly assessing post-operative ICU admission.
Why the study?
Both under- and over-triage to the ICU after surgery are associated with harm, and existing evidence regarding the utility of heart rate variability to predict post-operative ICU need following non-cardiac surgery was unclear.
Does heart rate variability (HRV) predict post-operative critical care and ICU-related outcomes in patients undergoing non-cardiac surgery?
Systematic Review (n=5,195)
Does heart rate variability (HRV) predict post-operative critical care and ICU-related outcomes in patients undergoing non-cardiac surgery?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Current evidence is too small and heterogeneous to support the routine incorporation of heart rate variability measurements into post-operative ICU triage following non-cardiac surgery.
Introduction Admissions to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) following surgery are common, and both under- and over-triage of patients to the ICU post-operatively have been associated with harm. Heart rate variability (HRV) is a non-invasive, indirect measure of autonomic nervous system activity, and a predictor of several adverse events in various settings, including the peri-operative setting. There is increasing literature around improving risk stratification tools for patients in the immediate post-operative period, however it is unclear what evidence exists about the potential utility of HRV as a predictor of outcomes related to post-operative ICU need. Objective To map the current literature on the utility of HRV as a tool to support ICU triage decision making in the immediate post-operative period following non-cardiac surgery. Methods EMBASE, MEDLINE, and Cochrane Library were searched from inception to February 2026 for studies of any design, published in English. Duplicates were removed, and title and abstract screening determined studies suitable for full-text screening. Full texts were then screened, and data were extracted from relevant studies including study characteristics, HRV measurement methods and clinical outcomes. Relevant outcomes included related to post-operative ICU need or those that might be serve as proxies in identifying a deteriorating patient who may benefit from post-operative ICU admission Results The search strategy identified 7,826 studies, of which 6,884 were screened following removal of duplicates; of these 71 full texts were assessed for eligibility. Thirty-seven studies were included, totalling 5,195 patients. Of the 37 studies, 94.6% (n=35) were observational. Studies differed considerably in terms of methodology and HRV measurement parameters as well as timing of HRV measurement. Only one study directly assessed ICU admission. Four studies assessed ICU length of stay and two the need for vasoactive medications. The most assessed outcomes were cardiac related, and the most frequently studied surgical cohorts were colorectal and vascular. Conclusions The evidence base for HRV in predicting post-operative critical care outcomes is small and heterogeneous, and direct evidence around HRV utility in post-operative ICU triage is almost absent. Current evidence does not support routine incorporation of HRV into post-operative ICU triage practice. Future prospective studies should investigate optimal HRV measurements and timing in this cohort of patients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cann et al. (2026) conducted a systematic review in Patients in the immediate post-operative period following non-cardiac surgery (n=5,195). Heart rate variability (HRV) measurement was evaluated on Outcomes related to post-operative ICU need (ICU admission, ICU length of stay, need for vasoactive medications, and cardiac-related proxy outcomes). Heart rate variability had a small, heterogeneous evidence base across 37 studies (n=5,195), with only 1 study directly assessing post-operative ICU admission.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: