Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Urban analysis of historic cities faces a persistent methodological fragmentation. Existing approaches tend to operate within disciplinary fields, addressing either historical evolution, present spatial configuration, or cultural meaning, but rarely in an integrated manner. This paper proposes a taxonomy for the layered analysis of historic urban landscapes, and at the same time , it tests the validity of a conceptual framework developed around the proposed taxonomy. Conducting a systematic literature review , the taxonomy is structured around the 30 papers selected out of 169 retrieved. Scale of analysis was not included as exclusion criteria, resulting in a variety of case studies or approaches. Classifying the retrieved papers around the field o f study, theory, ontological, epistemological and methodological roles, the taxonomy uncovers a structural order of analysis that links t o the research questions and guides the scope of the urban analysis. While classifying the data, it became increasingly clear t hat largely, there are three sequences used in historic urban analysis: diachronic, synchronic and interpretative. The taxonomy g uides towards a sequential approach that links the urban development (diachronic), analysis of the present city in relation (analyt ical) to the historical stages and cultural meaning and attributes of the built space (interpretative), addressing a structural pro blem in HUL methodology: the absence of a unified methodology for interpreting tangible and intangible layers. The paper contributes by proposing a structural order that can be further developed into a framework. By systematically linking these stages – from historical development to present - day configurations and cultural meanings – this framework addresses a crit ical gap in urban studies, where traditional analysis often prioritises either quantitative spatial metrics or qualitative narratives, without a cohesive methodological bridge. Further research should test the applicability of the conceptual framework to a case study and also the inter-dependence of the proposed sequence: iterative, layered or strictly sequential.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daria Sarca (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: