Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction and objective: This article aims to examine how psychotherapeutic approaches that diverge from traditional theories of change and emphasise non-pathological indicators of effectiveness, such as solution-focused brief therapy, can gain wide recognition within mental health care. Materials and methods: For this purpose, indicators and criteria of effectiveness proposed within mainstream therapeutic approaches are contrasted with a model whose theory of change and clinical practice depart from traditional frameworks. Solution-focused brief therapy was used as an illustrative example, given the dominant position it has achieved in Finland following its inclusion in the public health system. This approach is grounded in clinical observation and informed by a theory rooted in social constructionism. Results: Solution-focused brief therapy demonstrated effectiveness both through client-centred measures and classical indicators of efficacy. Nevertheless, the approach encountered various challenges on its path to wider recognition. The promoted indicators of effectiveness vary from those of the medical model by prioritising clients’ feedback related to progress towards goals and personal strengths instead of pathology. However, it cannot be assumed that similar alignment will characterise other emerging therapeutic modalities. This raises critical questions about whether legislation and policymakers should continue to privilege established frameworks or instead create more flexible pathways for evaluating and adopting new treatments. Conclusions: Arguments for a balanced perspective that values rigorous evidence while also fostering openness to innovation and diversity were put forward in order to encourage continuous development of psychotherapy to better respond to the evolving needs of clients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Żak et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: