Key result
Updated ERC/ESICM post-resuscitation guidelines increase accurate OHCA neuroprognostication by ~38 percentage points.
Why the study?
Real-world validation was needed to compare the prognostic-therapeutic management and neurological outcomes of comatose OHCA patients across two distinct time periods reflecting advances in post-cardiac arrest care and the 2025 ERC-ESICM guidelines.
Does implementation of the 2025 ERC/ESICM guidelines improve the accuracy and timeliness of neurological outcome prognostication compared to the 2014 ERC/ESICM guidelines in comatose adult patients following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest?
Cohort (n=243)
No
Does implementation of the 2025 ERC/ESICM guidelines improve the accuracy and timeliness of neurological outcome prognostication compared to the 2014 ERC/ESICM guidelines in comatose adult patients following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest?
Real-world implementation of the 2025 ERC/ESICM post-resuscitation guidelines substantially improved both the accuracy (86.8% vs. 48.7%) and timeliness of neurological outcome prediction in comatose survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May refine post-arrest prognostication accuracy; extends 2014 guidelines but leaves open prospective validation before practice change.
Background/Objectives: To compare the prognostic and therapeutic management, as well as the neurological outcomes, of comatose patients following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest(OHCA) across two distinct time-periods, reflecting advances in post-cardiac arrest(CA) care and neuro-logical prognostication. Methods: a retrospective, single-centre study at Careggi University Hos-pital in Florence, Italy. We compared the prognostic-therapeutic management and neurological outcomes of all comatose adult patients (aged ≥18years) admitted to the Emergency Depart-ment(ED) following OHCA between 1 June 2018 and 31 May 2020 with those admitted between 1 January 2024 and 31 December 2025. Neurological outcome was assessed using the Glas-gow-Pittsburgh-Cerebral-Performance-Category(CPC) scale. CPC scores of 1–2 were classified as favourable outcomes, whereas scores of 3–5 were considered poor outcomes. Results: A total of 121 and 122 patients were included in the 2018–2020 and 2024–2025 cohorts, respectively. Using the 2014-ERC/ESICM guidelines, 59/121 patients(48.7%) were correctly identified. In the 2024–2025 cohort, the 2025-ERC/ESICM guidelines correctly identified 106/122 patients(86.8%)(46/62 with poor and 60/60 with favourable outcomes). Neurophysiological prognostication was per-formed earlier in this cohort than in the 2018–2020 cohort. Applying the 2025 guidelines to the 2018–2020 cohort increased the number of patients with correctly predicted outcomes to 93/121(76.8%). Conclusions: Implementation of the 2025-ERC/ESICM guidelines improved the accuracy and timeliness of neurological prognostication after OHCA. The more recent cohort un-derwent prognostication that focused on identifying both poor and good outcomes, based on a greater number of complementary predictors, which potentially increased reliability. Accurate neurological prognostication is particularly important in patients with poor outcomes, who were more frequently managed with withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Scarpino et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) (n=243). 2025 ERC/ESICM guidelines for neurological prognostication (2024–2025 cohort) vs. 2014 ERC/ESICM guidelines for neurological prognostication (2018–2020 cohort) was evaluated on Correctly identified neurological outcome assessed by the Glasgow-Pittsburgh Cerebral Performance Category (CPC) scale. The 2025 ERC/ESICM guidelines correctly identified neurological outcomes after OHCA in 86.8% of patients (2024-2025 cohort) compared to 48.7% using the 2014 guidelines (2018-2020 cohort).
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: