Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Postharvest technologies are often assessed using performance measures that may not fully support their broader functional claims. To address this gap, a scoping review was conducted following JBI methodology and PRISMA-ScR guidance to map functional claims and their supporting validation evidence across 160 primary studies published between 2017 and September 2026. Based on the findings, the Postharvest-to-Decision Validation (P2D-VAL) framework was developed as a structured assessment process. Each study is classified into one of six primary functional claims: target detection, food-state estimation, prediction, recommendation, intervention, and adaptive closed-loop operation and systematically assessed through three validation-evidence dimensions: signal-to-state validity (S), physical-scale representativeness (R), and transportability (T), alongside a decision-intervention pathway component (C), with applicability determined for each component. The resulting assessment is documented in a Validity Passport, recording supporting evidence, evaluated conditions, supported claim boundaries, unsupported extensions, and reassessment triggers. Across the studies, intervention (43.1%) and food-state estimation (39.4%) predominated; recommendation and adaptive operation represented only 2.5%. Independent signal-to-state testing was reported in 3 of 87 applicable studies; 61 of 68 scale-applicable studies lacked demonstrated larger-scale representativeness, and 109 of 160 remained confined to original application conditions. Among 23 studies with stronger signal-to-state evidence and applicable scale assessments, 22 showed limited scale representativeness, illustrating that evidence across dimensions does not necessarily coincide. Only one study demonstrated sensor-triggered intervention, and none demonstrated adaptive feedback. The finalized framework was subsequently applied to eight external studies, independent of the framework-development evidence, to illustrate its applicability across heterogeneous postharvest technologies. Qualitative comparison with seven selected validation and decision-readiness approaches highlighted their complementary emphases and P2D-VAL’s integrated assessment of claims, evidence dimensions, decision pathways, and supported boundaries. The framework helps identify validation gaps and clarify claim boundaries.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hassan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: