Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Tholonic Psyche in Jung's Language: Analytical Psychology as a Precursor Structure The companion paper asked whether the tholonic N-D-C model could give structure to Jung's model of the psyche, and found a partial fit: the dynamics fit well, and the figures fit less well. This paper reverses the direction of the question. It takes the tholonic structure as the foundation and adopts Jung's concepts to describe it, in the way an older theory survives inside a newer one as a special case. The model has 3 roles: Negotiation (N, the emergent, unsettled state), Definition (D, the bounding and excluding role), and Contribution (C, the flowing and integrating role). To keep the revision from manufacturing its own fit, an adjustment rule is fixed before any adjustment is made: a change to Jung's model is admitted only if Jung's own texts support it, if it removes a contradiction or a gap Jung acknowledged, or if it yields a new prediction that could fail. Under this rule, 7 revisions are proposed. Six pass the rule, the last of them only in part: the persona as a negotiated child state, the shadow as a position rather than a figure, the Self as 2 positions, the quaternity as a closing rather than a fourth element, inflation as 2 conditions, and the anima and animus as one ungendered role, the soul. For the soul, Jung's German text supports the term: it names the inner attitude Seele (soul) almost everywhere and uses "Anima" only twice (CW 6 ¶803, editors' note). It does not support removing the gender, because Jung's own definition keeps the soul contrasexual (CW 6 ¶805), so that part is held as a proposal. One revision is a genuine disagreement (individuation as open-ended rather than terminal). With the revisions in place, the paper restates the tholonic model entirely in Jungian vocabulary: each position, relation, and failure of the structure is given its Jungian name and a definition. The paper then asks whether the structure generates Jung's catalogue of figures. A seating places the Great Mother, the Wise Old Man, the Child, the Hero, the Trickster, the persona, the soul, the 2 shadows, and the Self at distinct positions. Checking the seating against Jung's text corrected two points in the initial seating: the Trickster is Jung's "collective shadow figure" (CW 9i ¶484) and sits at the excluded side in transit, not at the negotiation itself; and Jung's own negative Wise Old Man is a malicious magician (CW 9i ¶¶413–415), not the rigid tyrant first assumed. The seating yields a prediction about Jung's observation that every archetype has a positive and a negative aspect (CW 9i ¶79): the negative aspect of a figure should be the characteristic failure of its own role, rigidity for D positions, engulfment for C positions, and failure to settle for N positions. A one-reader pilot against the sources gave 3 clear matches, 1 partial match, and 1 clear mismatch (the persona), and the prediction was refined for N positions. The refined prediction was then pre-registered and run on 11 masked passages coded blind by 3 AI models from different developers (Fleiss' kappa 0.92). It failed: 3 of the 4 scored figures were coded with another role's failure type (the animus as rigidity, the Hero as engulfment, Mercurius as unsettledness), against a pre-stated limit of 1. In a formal check with 2 description-logic reasoners, none of the 24 one-to-one assignments of the 4 failure types to the 4 role classes, the predicted one included, is consistent with the codes. A second pre-registered test, of the Self revision on the 59 chronologically ordered mandala dreams of CW 12, found Self imagery coded "achieved or united" later in the series than imagery coded "given or enclosing", but not significantly (one-sided p = 0.080 against a pre-stated 0.05), and the rank correlation over all 59 items was near zero (Spearman's rho 0.08). A textual check of CW 7 ¶254 supports the persona revision. The conclusion is limited accordingly: the tholonic structure is the more general and more internally consistent of the 2 models, and Jung's model can be recovered from it with stated corrections, but the one prediction of the seating that has been tested failed, and the seating of the figures does not stand as proposed. Whether the structure is also more accurate about actual psyches depends on empirical tests that neither paper performs. Version 1.4. Preprint; not peer reviewed. The companion files carry each quoted Collected Works passage by its source reference rather than its text; Appendix A states how to rebuild the full coder packets. Second paper of a 3-paper series on Jung and the psyche (preceded by Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24151111, and followed by A Tholonic Psychology of the Individual).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jeffrey Milton (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: