Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Eighth note in the QMEM series on qubit-versus-qutrit antipodal tables. Preprint, version 1; not peer reviewed. This note places the results of the series in the standard prepare-and-measure framework for quantum dimension witnesses. A sender prepares one of m pairs of states, a receiver performs one of n binary measurements, and the observed correlators define a half-difference table D = ½(E⁺ − E⁻), evaluated using linear witnesses and the factorization norm γ₂. Main results Qubit bound. Every qubit strategy satisfies γ₂(D) ≤ 1, even with shared randomness and without assuming antipodal correlations. Dimension versus quantumness. Without the antipodal restriction, qutrits attain γ₂ = 2/√3, for example using four mutually unbiased bases in ℂ³, verified in exact arithmetic. Classical trits attain the same value on a 2 × 2 table. Moreover, shared randomness can transform any strategy into one with antipodal correlations while preserving its half-difference table. Thus antipodality alone does not establish a quantum advantage. Classical-trit theorem. For independent preparation and measurement devices, classical trits satisfy γ₂(D) ≤ 1 on exactly antipodal data, whereas qutrits can exceed this bound. A new exact rational certificate establishes γ₂ ≥ 1.007522, improving the previous lower bound of 1.007479. Together with the universal upper bound proved in Note 7, this gives 1.007522 ≤ κ ≤ 3/(2√2) ≈ 1.058972. Consequently, exactly antipodal correlations with γ₂(D) > 1 exclude qubits and classical trits under the stated independence assumption. Blind spots of dimension witnesses. Previous no-advantage theorems identify configurations in which γ₂(D) cannot exceed one: pairs with a common average state, balanced antipodal pairs, traceless measurements, and measurements annihilating a state whose eigenvalues are all at most ½. Noise robustness. For a classical trit with antipodality defect ε, an explicit construction attains γ₂(D)² = (4 − 3ε)/(4(1 − ε)). The conjecture that this is also the universal upper bound is supported by numerical searches but remains unproved. The witness for exactly antipodal data and its exclusion of qubits under depolarising noise are rigorous. The approximate visibility threshold of 0.993 against classical trits is conditional on the conjecture and the specified noise model. Experimental considerations. Idealised statistical estimates suggest approximately 55,000 trials per setting for a 5σ violation using the certified antipodal table, compared with a visibility threshold of 0.866 and a few hundred trials for a dimension-only test based on mutually unbiased bases. These estimates do not constitute a complete finite-statistics protocol. Device independence is an experimental assumption, not a property certified by the witness. The note builds on established research in prepare-and-measure dimension witnesses, including Gallego et al. (2010), Wehner et al. (2008), Bowles et al. (2014), and Diviánszky et al. (2023). It does not claim priority for the general dimension-witness framework. The accompanying reproducibility archive contains the exact rational certificate, verification scripts, numerical searches, preregistrations, and SHA-256 manifests.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vasily Psykovsky (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: