Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ninth note in the QMEM series on qubit-versus-qutrit antipodal tables. Preprint, version 1; not peer reviewed. This note compares the factorization norms of classical and quantum prepare-and-measure correlations in arbitrary finite dimension. It establishes an envelope theorem, determines the optimal classical constant for antipodal tables in every dimension, identifies an even–odd distinction in the achievable quantum advantage, and provides a computer-assisted noise certificate for the qutrit dimension witness introduced in Note 8. Main results Envelope theorem. For arbitrary pairs of quantum states with average states σₖ and arbitrary binary measurements, the half-difference table D satisfies γ₂(D)² ≤ tr(ω) for every positive semidefinite operator ω dominating all σₖ. The result does not require antipodality. Minimizing tr(ω) gives a semidefinite-programming bound, unifying the common-average theorem and several earlier no-advantage results. If all averages lie in the convex hull of r states, then γ₂(D)² ≤ r. Exact classical constant. Every classical d-level antipodal table satisfies γ₂(D)² ≤ min(v, d − v), where v is the dimension of the span of the measurement response vectors. The bound implies the exact optimal classical constant κ_cl(d) = √⌊d/2⌋, attained in every dimension. The proof combines a rank bound derived from John's ellipsoid theorem, the envelope theorem, and a trace–rank inequality for nonnegative column-stochastic matrices. Parity of the quantum advantage. The optimal quantum and classical constants coincide in every even dimension, where both equal √(d/2). In every odd dimension d = 2r + 1, the quantum squared constant exceeds the classical value r by at least 0.0151. Thus the quantum advantage in this factorization-norm criterion exists precisely in odd dimensions. Dimension witnesses in every dimension. Under the assumption of independent preparation and measurement devices, exactly antipodal data satisfying γ₂(D)² > r exclude quantum systems of dimension at most 2r and classical systems with at most 2r + 1 levels. Such correlations are achievable by quantum systems of dimension 2r + 1. Rigorous noise threshold. For the certified 4 × 8 qutrit witness of Note 8, a branch-and-bound computation with exact-rational verification of every leaf establishes that classical trits with antipodality defect at most 1/100 cannot reach the qubit witness bound. Under the specified depolarising-noise model, the threshold for excluding classical trits therefore equals the rigorous qubit threshold: visibility greater than 0.9925339. This removes the conjectural dependence of the earlier threshold for this particular witness; the general conjecture remains open. Scope and limitations The comparison concerns the factorization norm of antipodal prepare-and-measure data, not a universal advantage of quantum systems for every communication task. Independence of the devices is assumed rather than certified. The noise theorem applies to the specified witness, while the general classical-trit noise conjecture remains unresolved. Reproducibility The accompanying supplementary archive documents the analytical checks, preregistered numerical tests, branch-and-bound trees, exact-rational verification procedures, execution logs, and SHA-256 manifests. The manuscript provides commands for reproducing the computer-assisted theorem. This work builds on established dimension-witness and factorization-norm literature and on the preceding eight notes in the QMEM series.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vasily Psykovsky (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: