Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this paper, I compare eleven espresso puck-preparation techniques (a wedge distributor, three needle-and-tamp protocols, and seven robot-arm shaking programs forming a kinematic basis set) in 110 manually pressure-profiled extractions on a home lever machine. Screening on the pressure-time integral, reproduced to 1.9 % by the manual lever, enforces input equality and certifies a human arm as a controlled pressure source. Mean extraction yield and strength differ, but every significant pairwise difference crosses a roast-batch boundary carrying a comparable systematic, so conclusions are robustness statements: across every batch assumption, zone convention, and input-screening band examined, a horizontal sweep with the cup axis aligned with the direction of travel (V7) is the only preparation that holds first or second place on a reader-weighted preference map, and it is the recommendation that survives. The double-tamp question is answered in the negative: the one-sided 95 % upper confidence bound on the extraction-yield difference, double minus single tamp, is -0.12 percentage points (+0.04 after multiplicity correction), with no detectable spread effect. The kinematic contrasts are bounded null at ten runs per technique, and a second experiment targeting the popular densification hypothesis is a quantified negative: the year-stored pellet tracks dissolved solids, any residual preparation signal below 0.11 percentage points at 95 % confidence. Three practical findings follow: (1) distribution, not tamping, is the active lever of puck preparation, and V7 with a single tamp is the batch-robust choice; (2) grind consistency, not machine cost, sets the reproducibility ceiling, favoring investment in the grinder over the machine; (3) preparation effects match the roast-batch systematic in size, so roast consistency must be controlled alongside technique. The dataset and deterministic pipeline are deposited; the study is offered as a model of honest measurement practice on an accessible system.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maximilian Alberth (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: