Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Academic studies of the policy process are heavily dominated by theoretical frameworks developed in the Global North, creating a fundamental mismatch when applied to non‐Western contexts. This article addresses a critical research question, how must universal policy process theories be adapted to accurately analyze the distinct political, social, and institutional realities of Latin America? Utilizing a context‐sensitive literature‐review approach, this study evaluates previous regional scholarship by filtering its findings through the lens of Cairney and Heikkila's six systemic elements: actors, institutions, networks, ideas, context, and events. The findings reveal that Latin American policymaking operates under profound structural asymmetries, including hyper‐presidential architectures paired with institutional weakness, high informality, severe socioeconomic inequality, and a “hierarchical capitalism” dominated by family conglomerates. Rather than treating these features as mere background conditions, the article articulates how they function as analytical mechanisms that systematically reconfigure policy formulation and implementation. As its primary contribution, the article offers a theoretical framework that disentangles regional policy dynamics into three analytical categories: trans‐contextual mechanisms, mechanisms requiring contextual specification, and explanatory boundary limits. Furthermore, to advance situated policy studies, it conceptualizes five analytical fallacies that scholars must explicitly avoid: epistemological neutrality, convergence, transplantation, institutional determinism, and the Aristotelian fallacy of division. This framework moves beyond treating Latin American features as mere “deviant cases,” offering a more plural and rigorous theoretical dialog between Northern paradigms and Global South realities.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nicolás Bentancur (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: