Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The genus Pterocarya (Juglandaceae) is a relict tree lineage with a disjunct distribution across East Asia and the Hyrcanian forests of West Asia. We compared the two core chloroplast barcodes, matK and rbcL , across six reference taxa and then tested candidate diagnostic states for P. fraxinifolia in 100 individuals from 20 Iranian populations. The same sequence data were also used for complementary phylogenetic, divergence-time, and biogeographic analyses. matK recovered four reference haplotypes and unique sequences for two of the six taxa; rbcL recovered three haplotypes and a unique sequence for one taxon, and combining the two loci did not improve on matK . Within P. fraxinifolia , we detected six matK haplotypes and two rbcL haplotypes. Four of the five states that appeared diagnostic in the reference comparison were polymorphic in the population sample, whereas one matK state remained fixed across all 100 individuals. The marker-specific trees and the concatenated maximum-likelihood analysis resolved several terminal East Asian relationships, but the deeper placement of P. fraxinifolia remained weakly supported. Fossil-constrained BEAST analysis placed crown Pterocarya at 30.81 Ma (95% HPD: 28.00-33.64 Ma). The two biogeographic models differed at the deeper nodes: DEC reconstructed a widespread West-East Asian crown range (AB), whereas the BBM graphic retained a mixed A/B crown state; B nevertheless had the highest numerical probability (96.70%) in the BBM output. Both models inferred one dispersal and one vicariance overall, although they placed these events at different nodes, and neither inferred extinction under the extant-only two-area framework. Overall, the barcode results show limited species-level resolution and demonstrate why putatively diagnostic states identified from single reference sequences require population-level validation. The biogeographic results likewise represent a simplified history of the surviving lineages and are best interpreted alongside the much richer fossil record of Pterocarya .
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sabbagh et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: