Key result
Each minute of cardiac arrest delay reduces 1-month survival by ~2 percentage points.
Why the study?
Early defibrillation is the main modifiable determinant of survival after shockable out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, but studies restricted to defibrillated patients cannot observe those whose rhythms degenerated before responder arrival. This study sought to quantify that loss and its population-level consequences.
Does earlier contact and defibrillation improve rhythm preservation and 1-month survival in bystander-witnessed adult out-of-hospital cardiac arrest?
Cohort (n=368,496)
Yes
Does earlier contact and defibrillation improve rhythm preservation and 1-month survival in bystander-witnessed adult out-of-hospital cardiac arrest?
Each minute of delay in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest reduces the proportion of patients with a shockable rhythm by approximately 5% and decreases 1-month survival by about 2 percentage points, highlighting that much of the survival benefit of faster response comes from reaching patients before rhythm degeneration.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Rapid decline in shockable rhythms after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest supports immediate CPR; hypothesis-generating for optimal rhythm analysis timing.
Background: Early defibrillation is the principal modifiable determinant of survival after shockable out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, but studies restricted to defibrillated patients cannot observe those who had degenerated before a responder arrived. We quantified this loss and its population-level consequences. Methods: We analysed 368,496 bystander-witnessed adult arrests of presumed cardiac origin in the All-Japan Utstein Registry (2005-2024). Modified Poisson models with marginal standardization estimated the proportion with a shockable rhythm at emergency medical services (EMS) contact and 1-month survival as functions of elapsed time. Assuming exchangeability within strata of bystander category and age, we estimated the additional survivors had patients reached at 15 minutes been reached at 5-10 minutes. Results: The adjusted proportion with a shockable rhythm was 33.1% (95% CI, 30.2-36.5) at 1 minute, 24.7% (24.4-24.9) at 9 minutes and 8.4% (8.0-8.8) at 30 minutes, a relative decline of 4.8% per minute between 5 and 30 minutes. Adjusted 1-month survival fell from 39.5% (38.4-40.6) at 9 minutes to 15.9% (15.1-16.7) at 20 minutes after EMS defibrillation, and from 63.5% (59.9-67.3) at 3 minutes to 47.2% (44.4-50.0) at 10 minutes after bystander defibrillation; each minute cost 2.1 to 2.7 percentage points in both pathways. Shifting the 119,982 patients reached at 15 minutes to 5-10 minutes yielded 6,465 additional survivors (6,259-6,669) over 20 years (323 per year; number needed to treat, 18.6), 59.1% through rhythm preservation. Family-witnessed arrests and the other bystander category, predominantly institutional, accounted for 77.4%. Conclusions: The proportion of patients shockable at EMS contact was approximately 5% lower for each additional minute after collapse, and survival fell by about two percentage points per minute whoever delivered the shock. Under the model's assumptions, most of the benefit of faster contact derives from reaching patients while still shockable, chiefly in arrests witnessed by family members or in institutional settings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kubo et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (n=368,496). Elapsed time from witnessed cardiac arrest to EMS contact or first defibrillation vs. Earlier contact or defibrillation time (e.g., 5-10 minutes vs 15 minutes) was evaluated on Proportion with a shockable rhythm at EMS contact and 1-month survival (NNT 18.6). Each minute of delay after cardiac arrest reduced shockable rhythm at EMS contact by 4.8% and 1-month survival by 2.1-2.7 percentage points.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: