Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Polls indicate a marked decline in trust in political institutions across Western democracies, alongside declining trust in specific areas of science and sharp ideological polarisation in attitudes toward science, most notably in the United States. This paper investigates a common factor in the breakdown of trust in both domains: seemingly intractable disagreement. The argument proceeds in three stages. First, I distinguish three sources of disagreement – factual, value-based and identity-based – and examine their bearing on politics and on science. Factual and value disagreements are, in principle, open to resolution through evidence and reasoning; identity-based disagreements resist such remedies. Second, drawing on Bernard Williams and Christine Korsgaard, I develop the idea of identity-constituting commitments: commitments central to constructing our personal and social identities. Third, using a modified version of Katherine Hawley's commitment-based account of trust, I argue that where disagreements stem from such commitments, not only are the preconditions for trust absent, but there are also identity-based reasons for distrust. The breakdown of trust in contexts of strong polarisation is centrally linked with clashes of identities and is not merely epistemic. This also explains why appeals to “follow the science”, fact-checking and improved communication have failed to rebuild trust.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maria Baghramian (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: