Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Women’s agricultural cooperatives are widely promoted as instruments of empowerment and are typically evaluated by whether they change women’s individual outcomes: income, assets, or participation in decisions. This paper argues that such measures miss what is analytically decisive: how the power women generate through collective organization comes to be recognized as legitimate, or not, across the different institutional fields a cooperative brings them into. Drawing on fieldwork with women in cooperatives in the arid province of Tata, southeastern Morocco, and taking the single claim rather than the woman as the unit of analysis, it traces how power is converted, unevenly, into legitimated agency as claims move across the household, community, market, and state. The central finding is an asymmetry: the power a woman generates travels across these fields, but the legitimacy that would make her claims rightful does not; it must be won anew in each field, on that field’s own terms. This non-portability produces the unevenness the analysis maps, a woman’s claims contained in some fields and reconfigured in others. The paper advances four arguments: it extends Kandiyoti’s patriarchal bargain from cross-contextual to multi-scalar variation; it specifies legitimacy as field-specific and non-portable, distinct from portable power; it shows how formally neutral economic mechanisms produce gendered effects, connecting the argument to feminist and development economics; and it treats the cooperative as an ambivalent terrain that makes multi-field agency observable. Rather than asking whether cooperatives empower women, it shows how, and how unevenly, the agency they generate is legitimated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Khadija Kaffa (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: