Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The standardization of soundscape assessment introduced by the InternationalOrganization for Standardization through the ISO 12913 series has establisheda global framework for the analysis of acoustic environments basedon Perceived Affective Qualities (PAQ). However, the ecological validity ofthese standardized attributes in complex real-world contexts, such as theurban–port interface, remains a subject of ongoing scientific investigation.The present study analyzes data from a large-scale survey (number of participants= 722) conducted in Genova (Italy) on a non-WEIRD population.The survey instrument was developed through a re-elaboration of the circularmodel proposed by the International Organization for Standardization inISO 12913-2, integrating a corpus-based linguistic approach that enabled acritical reflection on the assumptions underlying the original model.Results from Principal Component Analysis (PCA) show a structural discrepancybetween in-situ and laboratory settings: specifically, the theoreticalbipolarity of the Eventfulness axis collapses in-situ (r = 0.01), while it is restoredin audio-only conditions (r = -0.21), ruling out purely lexical biases.Furthermore, the study identifies sound moderation descriptors (e.g.,”misurato” (measured) and ”contenuto” (restrained)) as primary markers offunctional comfort, and familiarity as a cognitive filter that mitigates annoyance. In contrast, the emergence of more severe and polarized labels inthe audio setting (e.g., "ossessivo" (obsessive), "improvviso" (sudden)), despitethe use of similar acoustic stimuli, suggest that laboratory tests mayoverestimate annoyance by stripping acoustic events of their ecological identityand normality anchors. We propose that future standardized protocols,particularly ISO 12913-2, should incorporate linguistic corpora analysis asa preliminary step to calibrate descriptors, ensuring that assessment frameworksaccount for the contextual congruence and semantic nuances inherentin real-world perception.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ferretti et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: