Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper reads what the teacher-student relation this series speaks of looks like. The series does not define all teacher-student relations. The teacher-student relation it reads has as its premise that the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating this student as an end, and not merely as a means. There is no teacher who stands purely at 15DD; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and after falling back this end can turn back. Where it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means, that relation is not within the teacher-student relation this series reads. Where someone who teaches a course only teaches the course well, it cannot be read which kind this is; it is not judged, nor is it within the scope of this series: that is teaching, and teaching can carry no direction at all; a relation in which the course is only taught well is not what this series sets out to read. The teacher is a party in a relation, not a post. Where, in some matter, one party teaches and the other learns, and the teaching actually enters the conditions of occurrence at the learner's end, there is a teacher-student relation in that matter; once is enough. Titles do not define it. Posts, schools and their provisions are acknowledged but not judged; of the authority a construct gives, the source and the force are not judged, and how the teacher uses it is read. A teacher and each student form one relation apiece, entered on separate accounts, pair by pair; among teacher, student and parents, the series reads only the relation between teacher and student. The student's standing as an end is full from the start; what he can do and how much he understands grow as he learns; the two books are kept apart. That the student never chose this teacher does not give the teacher the position of deciding his direction for him; that he cannot decide for himself to walk away does not place his asking, his refusing and his not avowing, in particular matters, at the teacher's disposal. The object layer reads the relation in which the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction; at the operation layer the teacher confirms only his own end. This paper interfaces with Han Yu's "On Teachers" and with several chapters of the Analects on teachers. It does not prove that teachers headed in the 15DD direction are better than other teachers, nor that this is the only kind of teacher-student relation, nor that teachers ought to treat the student as an end, nor that a student ought to take the one who teaches him as his teacher. 这一篇读这个系列所说的师生关系是什么样子。这个系列不给一切师生关系下定义。它读的师生关系,以老师那一端在 15DD 方向上为前提:在一件件事上,朝把这个学生当作目的那一面去,而不只把他当作手段。没有纯在 15DD 上的老师;方向按一次运作读,回落照读,回落了,这一端能回过头来。读得出学生只被当作手段的,这一段不在这个系列读的师生关系里。教课的人只把课教好的,读不出是哪一种,不判,也不在这个系列的射程里:那是教,教可以什么方向都不带;只把课教好的这一段,不是这个系列要读的。 老师是关系里的一方,不是一个职位。在某一件事上,一方教,另一方学,教实际进入了学的那一端的发生条件,这一件事上就有师生关系;一次也是。名分不定义它。职位、学校与它们的规定,认而不判;构给的权限,来源与效力不判,老师怎样用它,照读。一位老师与每一个学生各成一段,两两记账;老师、学生、父母之间,这个系列只读老师与学生这一段。 学生作为目的的地位从一开始就是满的;他会什么、懂多少,随学随长;两本账分开记。学生没有选过这位老师,不使老师取得替他定方向的位置;他不能自己决定走开,不使他在具体事项上的发问、回绝与不认领归老师支配。对象层读老师那一端在 15DD 方向上的那一段;操作层老师只确认自己这一端。这一篇与韩愈《师说》、《论语》论师的几章对接。它不证明 15DD 方向的老师比别的老师好,不证明师生关系只有这一种,不证明老师应当把学生当作目的,也不证明学生应当认老师。
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Han Qin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: