Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper reads what grows out of the back-and-forth. Expectation between teacher and student grows out of the dealings: what the teacher has praised and what he has frowned at, which time the student got it right and which time he did not, all become material. The teacher's expectation is a construct left at his own end; it does not turn into the student's duty, and does not certify that the student has avowed anything. Saying an expectation out loud is a form of questioning; hanging an expectation on what kind of person the student is fixes for him what something means to him, and slides in the direction of colonization. What counts as hanging a condition on it is drawn by function, not by topic; whether it takes hold depends on his later understanding and action, and also on whether his denial has anywhere to land. Compliance does not stand as proof of avowal: the student's saying "all right," doing as told, and doing it well are all only clues. Where the teacher's approval has become the measure of the student's own judgment, this is read by borrowing "superego internalization" from the Learning series; from outside only clues are seen, and confirmation lies at his end. The student's depending on the teacher to teach is the kind of dependency that is there in any case, and carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made, and that has locked the path to saying no, carries the direction of colonization. The direction is to make him no longer held by this one teacher; this is only a direction, and is not used as a measure. Where one student is used as the measure of another, what is read first is how the sentence lands with the one who hears it; if it also actually alters the situation of the one used as the measure, that relation is entered separately. This paper interfaces with the "Record of Learning" in the Book of Rites and with Locke's Some Thoughts Concerning Education; research on teacher expectations is taken only as material. It does not prove that teachers ought not to have expectations, nor that praise is harmful, nor that a student who depends on a teacher has not grown, nor that any one way of praising is bound to head one way. 这一篇读一来一回里长出来的东西。师生之间的期待从来往里长出来:老师夸过什么、对什么皱眉,学生哪一次做对、哪一次没做到,都成为材料。老师的期待是他这一端留下的构,不落成学生的义务,也不认证学生认领了什么。说出期待是追问;把期待挂到学生是什么样的人上,是替他定下了一件事对他意味着什么,滑向殖民的方向。什么算挂上了,看功能,不看话题;成没成,看他此后的理解与行动,也看他的否认有没有地方落地。 顺从不代证认领:学生说「好」、照做、做得好,都只是线索。老师的赞许成了他自己判断的尺子的,借学习系列的「超我内化」读;从外面只见线索,确认在他那一端。学生依赖老师教,是本来就有的那一种依赖,不带殖民这个方向;被造出来、又锁住了说不之路的那一种,带殖民这个方向。方向是让他不再受制于这一位老师;这只是方向,不作尺子。拿一个学生作另一个学生的尺子,先读这句话怎样落到听的那一个那里;若也实际改动了被拿来作尺子的那一个的处境,那一段另记。 这一篇与《礼记·学记》、洛克《教育漫话》对接,教师期待的研究只作材料。它不证明老师不该有期待,不证明夸奖有害,不证明依赖老师的学生没有长成,也不证明哪一种夸法一定朝哪一向。
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Han Qin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: