Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study examines the paradoxical role of translanguaging and multimodal meaning-making in a Quintile 1 Grade 5 Science classroom in Nqutu, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. In this context, instructional materials are primarily English-based, while classroom interaction occurs fluidly in both English and isiZulu. While translanguaging and multimodal strategies are often celebrated as transformative, this study reveals a striking paradox: these practices facilitate conceptual access and participation yet are structured in ways that simultaneously reproduce linguistic hierarchies that privilege English over African languages. Using a case study approach grounded in ethnographic methods and multimodal discourse analysis, the study examines how a teacher and learners deploy a unitary semiotic repertoire including gestures, artifacts, and translanguaging to navigate scientific content in classroom communication. Three key findings emerge. First, the educator’s pedagogical choices shape the possibilities and limitations of translanguaging, and the practice is not inherently transformative. Second, while multimodality and spontaneous translanguaging scaffold access to the English-dominant curriculum, these practices remain largely teacher-directed, limiting dialogic engagement and learner epistemic authority. Third, a persistent tension exists between multilingual classroom discourse and the monolingual, English-only nature of assessment, revealing the ultimate paradox of translanguaging in post-colonial settings. These findings highlight the need for context-sensitive teacher education and assessment practices that recognize learners’ full linguistic and multimodal repertoires to enable equitable learning.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Msimango et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: