Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study examined how instructional approaches grounded in cognitive load theory influence students’ learning of trigonometry problems that differ in complexity based on the position of the pronumeral (numerator vs. denominator). We investigated the effects of problem-solving (PS), worked examples (WE), and comparison (C) approaches on performance outcomes, mental effort, and beliefs in achieving optimal best. Eighty secondary school students were randomly assigned to one of the three approaches. Participants completed a pre-test, an acquisition phase, a post-test, a concept test, and the Optimal Outcomes Questionnaire. For the more complex Type II problems, students in the WE and C groups significantly outperformed the PS group on the practice problems, highlighting the cognitive burden of unguided problem-solving. No significant differences were found in the post-test or concept test, indicating comparable transfer and conceptual understanding. For cognitive load measure, students in the PS group reported higher mental effort than those in the WE and C groups, confirming the advantage of guided approaches. Across the instructional approaches, students achieved relatively high levels of performance, particularly on the post-test, which may have contributed to similar perceptions of success and, consequently, comparable beliefs about their ability to attain optimal best. Importantly, correlations between mental effort and beliefs about achieving optimal best were nonsignificant, suggesting that cognitive load, as indexed by mental effort, was not associated with these beliefs. Overall, findings highlight the instructional value of worked examples and comparison strategies in reducing cognitive load and enhancing mathematics learning.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ngu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: