Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Opposing chemokine programs shape the glioblastoma (GBM) microenvironment, but it is unclear which features are reproducible once mathematical circularity is removed, and how strongly IDH status confounds chemokine–survival associations. We analysed 25 chemokines/receptors in three GBM cohorts—TCGA ( n = 159), CGGA ( n = 85), GSE16011 ( n = 159)—across RNA-seq and microarray. Co-expression was assessed by leave-one-gene-out (LOGO) correlation and, independently, by principal component analysis, factor analysis and network community detection, each performed separately in every cohort; reproducibility by Fisher r-to-z random-effects meta-analysis with REML and Hartung–Knapp sensitivity analyses (k = 3). Infiltration used independent, non-chemokine marker signatures. Survival analysis was restricted to IDH-wild-type GBM (per-1-SD Cox, FDR-corrected). The dual-axis architecture—a CXCR3-ligand module (CXCL9/CXCL10/CXCL11) opposed by an ELR⁺ CXCL/CCL20 myeloid module—survived LOGO correction and was recovered as the second principal component and as distinct network communities in each cohort independently (PC2 loading agreement ρ = 0.87–0.89). The first component was a shared infiltration gradient loading both modules positively, so they are not mutually exclusive. The modules were not equally reproducible: the CXCR3-ligand module showed minimal heterogeneity and excluded the null even under Hartung–Knapp (CXCL11 r = 0.56, I²=0%), whereas the ELR⁺/myeloid genes were directionally consistent but heterogeneous in magnitude (CCL20 r = − 0.43, I²=84%). Survival associations were fragile: CXCL10/CXCL11 were nominally protective (HR 0.70/0.73) but failed FDR (q = 0.19), with opposite directions in TCGA and CGGA (I²=91%). The co-expression architecture is reproducible—quantitatively for the CXCR3-ligand module, directionally for the ELR⁺/myeloid module—whereas chemokine–survival associations are non-reproducible, IDH-confounded and FDR-null.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
U et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: