Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
What does one look at to say whether a sentence is honest? This paper looks at two layers, both of them outside. The first: whether what is said matches the facts; this layer only describes. The second: where the sentence lands in the other person's position; judgment is at this layer. The norm, on the whole, does not support saying what is false, and that is a direction; it is the rule that says "saying what is false is wrong"; on a particular occasion, whether to say it is a judgment made by the speaker, and his to bear. So this paper does not say that saying what is false is wrong, and does not say it is right. Toward the hearer, a breach is of this kind: a sentence takes away the share that was his own to judge, however kind the reason. "For your own good" is not a ground: it reads the other's mind for him and then judges for him. A false sentence that stands between a violation and a person takes from the violator nothing that was his to judge, and is no breach; this does not depend on whether, in the end, it held anything back. Whether one says everything, like whether one says what is true or false, is only a means: if what is withheld was the other's own, for him to judge by, withholding it is taking it away; that it merely bears on his decision does not yet show this. Some sentences do not go past the place where the other decides for himself, and they simply stop there. 一句话诚实不诚实,看什么?这一篇分两层看,两层都在外面。第一层,说的和事实对不对得上;这一层只是描述。第二层,这句话落在对方的哪个位置上;判在这一层。规范总体上不支持说假话,这是方向;说「说假话不对」的是规则;到了具体的一回,说不说是说的人自己的一次判断,由他担。所以这一篇不说说假话是错的,也不说它是对的。对听的人,违反是这一种:一句话拿走了本来归他自己判的那一份,理由再善也是。「为你好」不作根据:那是替对方读了心,再替他判了。一句假话站到一次侵和人之间,没有拿走侵的人任何归他判的东西,没有违反;这不看最后挡没挡住。说不说全,和说真说假一样,只是手段:扣下的那一样若本来归对方据以作判断,扣下就是拿走;仅仅与他的决定有关,还推不出这一点。有些话没有越过对方作主的地方,就停在那里。 Related identifiers (References) 10.5281/zenodo.22970762 Is It Mine? (SAE Action Theory, Paper 3) 10.5281/zenodo.22970769 Can and Cannot (SAE Action Theory, Paper 4) 10.5281/zenodo.23874133 What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) 10.5281/zenodo.24030395 Is It Worth It? (SAE The Second Enlightenment, Paper 1) (Is part of the same series): 10.5281/zenodo.24294198 Prequel: What This Series Does Not Write 10.5281/zenodo.24294201 Paper 1: Justice: The Account and the Person 10.5281/zenodo.24294207 Paper 2: Courage: The Step Was Taken All the Same 10.5281/zenodo.24294217 Paper 4: Owning a Wrong: It Cannot Be Done in Another's Place 10.5281/zenodo.24294219 Paper 5: Forgiveness: The Account Carried Inside
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Han Qin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: