Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The three main-sequence disintegrating planets orbit a K dwarf at 4,400 kelvin, an M dwarf near 3,800 kelvin and a brighter K dwarf near 4,600 kelvin, on periods of 15.685 hours, 9.146 hours and 1.27 days respectively. Their published loss rates span one to ten Earth masses each billion years in absolute terms, yet their equilibrium temperatures cluster in the narrow band where silicate surfaces melt and vapour pressure climbs steeply. The budget derives each separation from period and adopted stellar mass, computes zero-albedo equilibrium temperature at each orbit, prices the stellar power intercepted by a stated planet cross-section, and compares the published loss rates after normalising by the adopted planet masses to obtain specific loss, the quantity that ranks how close each world is to its end. Headline values are engcomp k1255 a rsun engcomp = 2.814; engcomp k1255 teq k engcomp = 1518; engcomp k1255 rate earth gyr engcomp = 1; engcomp k1255 mass earth engcomp = 0.1; engcomp k1255 specific per gyr engcomp = 10; engcomp k22 a rsun engcomp = 1.657. The specific-loss ranking is the contribution, replacing three incomparable headline rates with a single like-for-like ordering.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: