Key result
Second cross-clamp during valve-sparing root replacement shows no increase in operative mortality or reintervention.
Why the study?
A second cross-clamp may be required to manage residual aortic regurgitation during valve-sparing root replacement, but its incidence, perioperative outcomes, and durability remain unclear.
Does a second cross-clamp for residual aortic regurgitation affect operative mortality, complications, and long-term reintervention compared to a single clamp in patients undergoing attempted valve-sparing root replacement?
Cohort (n=433)
No
Does a second cross-clamp for residual aortic regurgitation affect operative mortality, complications, and long-term reintervention compared to a single clamp in patients undergoing attempted valve-sparing root replacement?
Reapplying a cross-clamp for residual aortic regurgitation during valve-sparing root replacement—most often resulting in successful valve re-repair—achieves mild or less residual regurgitation without increasing operative mortality, postoperative complications, or long-term reintervention rates.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Second clamp may salvage the valve without early morbidity; leaves open durability concerns given higher reintervention rates in observational data.
Objectives For the management of residual aortic regurgitation, second cross-clamp for valve-sparing root replacement may be required, but incidence, perioperative outcomes, and durability remain unclear. We evaluated operative findings, management, and outcomes after second clamp. Methods We retrospectively reviewed 433 patients who underwent attempted valve-sparing root replacements at our institution from 2012 to 2025. Patients requiring a second or more clamp for residual aortic regurgitation were compared to single clamp patients. Long-term reintervention was estimated using cumulative incidence with death as a competing risk. Results Second clamp was required in 16 patients (3.7% of all attempted valve-sparing); 11 underwent re-repair and 5 were converted to aortic valve replacement. Median age was 57.5 years (range 29–68); 1 (6.2%) had bicuspid valves. Preoperative aortic regurgitation tended to be greater in second clamp than single clamp (P = 0.057). In second clamp, residual aortic regurgitation was severe in 2 patients (1 re-repair, 1 conversion), moderate in 9 (5 re-repair, 4 conversion), and mild in 5 (all re-repair). All second clamp patients left the operating room with mild or less residual aortic regurgitation. In single clamp, 1.0% had more than mild regurgitation without further repair attempt. Operative mortality was 0% vs 1.0% in second vs single clamp. Postoperative complication rates were comparable. Aortic valve reintervention did not differ significantly between groups; one second clamp patient required reintervention for recurrent aortic regurgitation. Conclusions For residual aortic regurgitation after valve-sparing root replacement, aortic valve re-repair may be a reasonable choice; however, more data and experience are warranted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Owolabi et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Residual aortic regurgitation during valve-sparing root replacement (n=433). Second or more cross-clamp for residual aortic regurgitation vs. Single cross-clamp was evaluated on Operative mortality. A second cross-clamp was required in 3.7% (16/433) of attempted valve-sparing root replacements, yielding 0% operative mortality vs 1.0% in single-clamp and similar aortic valve reintervention.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: