Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We check the quantitative statements near the sifting limit in A. Granville, "Sieving intervals and Siegel zeros" (Acta Arith. 205 (2022), 1–19; arXiv:2010.01211). (i) The last line of the proof of Proposition 2 uses a substitution valid at a different scale from the one chosen two lines earlier. Correctly, the secondary term is 4y log q/(log y)² at the proof's scale and 2(1+C(u)²) y log q/(log y)² at the scale of the statement; both exceed the printed 4C(u) y log q/(log y)². We state a corrected proposition for every scale. (ii) In the regime 1−β_q ≤ q^(−ε), the printed constant 2/ε does not follow from the argument, which gives at best (4+o(1))/ε. (iii) In the modified Cramér heuristic of Section 4 the parameter w is defined by y=(wz)² but used as y/(log x)²; with W = y/(log x)² throughout, the stated prime-gap predictions are unchanged. (iv) The induction proving Theorem 1 applies a relative error term near the boundary of its range; we give a uniform version with an absolute error. Theorem 1, its corollaries and the prime-gap predictions all stand. The record includes the note (PDF and LaTeX), a verification script, its output and the figure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ruqing Chen (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: