Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose As a contribution to Management Decision's The Practice of Making Decisions section, this paper helps organizations identify, assess and respond to harmful managerial decisions under incomplete information. It asks when harmful managerial behavior is likely to emerge, how it can be detected and what actions can prevent it. Design/methodology/approach The paper develops a diagnostic framework that distinguishes four conditions (benevolent error, culpable indifference, strategic exploitation and overt abuse) by documented conduct rather than inferred motive. It illustrates the framework's use with the public record of the Wells Fargo Community Bank sales practices case and a composite teaching case. Findings The four conditions are diagnostic categories, not fixed stages; managers move among them as incentives, governance constraints and reputational pressures change. The decisive observable difference is how decision makers respond to evidence of harm. Five tests (independent investigation, proportionality, mitigation, comparison of alternatives and reversal triggers set in advance) structure a documented review of continuing a harmful practice; they do not grant ethical clearance or override legal protections. Practical implications A six-step protocol, with illustrative thresholds that organizations calibrate, specifies what to monitor, when to intervene, who acts and which actions follow, and assigns responsibilities to boards, Human Resources (HR) and compliance officers. Social implications Early detection protects employees and customers who have the least power to protect themselves. Originality/value The framework links enabling conditions, warning signals and targeted interventions, helping ethics and compliance programs diagnose how managers respond to harm, not only which rule was broken.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cristini et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: