Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Site investigation reports frequently derive the shear strength of sands from small-box direct shear tests and carry those parameters straight into bearing capacity calculations. This study shows how such tests can yield physically implausible strength parameters and how those parameters propagate into misleading design values, using a 2026 investigation of a loose, saturated, erosion-derived alluvial sand at the Orle River, Auchi, Nigeria, as a forensic case. The reported allowable bearing pressures (38 values) were first reproduced to identify the calculation method. The raw shear-box records were then examined, and effective friction angles were derived independently from 28 Standard Penetration Test (SPT) results corrected for hammer energy, rod length and overburden, using two published correlations and energy ratios of 45–75%. Bearing capacities were recomputed like-for-like under effective stress for a shallow pad and at depth, and compared with SPT-based pile toe resistance. The reported values were reproduced exactly by Meyerhof’s equation for a 1 m square footing placed at the sample depth, with total unit weight and a factor of safety of 3. The shear-box tests on non-plastic sands gave friction angles of only 6.8–11.1°; they were run at normal stresses of 4.9–14.7 kPa, against 71–262 kPa in situ, and the shear stress was still rising when each test ended. The corrected SPT data (normalised blow counts of 7.7–14.7; relative density 0.36–0.49) indicate effective friction angles of 31–38°, and the gap survives every plausible energy-ratio assumption. For a 1 m pad at 1.5 m depth, the reported parameters give 34–40 kPa, against 159–463 kPa with friction angles of 28–32° under effective stress, an understatement of 5 to 12 times. The large reported capacities at depth (786–2357 kPa) arise from treating the sample depth as the embedment depth, and their agreement with SPT-based pile toe resistance (1067–2400 kPa) is coincidental. Direct shear tests on sands must be run to a defined failure at normal stresses that bracket field conditions and must be checked against in situ estimates; bearing calculations must use effective stress and the actual foundation geometry. Five simple checks are proposed that would catch this class of error in routine practice.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Igbeneghu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: