Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mainstream evolutionary anthropology, political history, and historical sociology have long treated the emergence of permanent architectural settlements, fortified statecraft, debt ledgers, standing armies, and theological dogmas as the rational, inevitable fruits of human cognitive superiority and agricultural leisure. This paper challenges this assumption of inevitable linear progress, demonstrating that civilizational statecraft was not catalyzed by an intellectual awakening, but by an environmental biophysical transition: chronic, species-wide neuroinflammation driven by the post-Neolithic adoption of domesticated Triticeae cereal monoculture. We begin by establishing the un-inflamed mammalian baseline, showing that sentient non-human mammals and primates exhibit empathy, grief, and lithic tool traditions without constructing fortified states or coercive apparatuses. We resolve the 300,000-year Paleolithic climate paradox, demonstrating that anatomically modern humans thrived across multiple warm, ecologically stable interglacials (MIS 5e, MIS 7, MIS 9) and utilized diverse wild starches without erecting cities or debt registries. We evaluate the Younger Dryas cometary airburst (∼10,800 BCE) and its global geomythological memory, contrast the open feasting arena of PPNA Göbekli Tepe (∼9500 BCE) with the defensive mudbrick grids and weapon enlargement of the PPNB phase transition, and analyze transoceanic seafaring as a vector of civilizational software. By synthesizing comparative crop rollouts (wheat versus rice, Andean tubers at Caral-Supe, and Mesoamerican maize), the social physics of complex contagions, and a composite clinical archetype of despotic autocrats and obsessive innovators, we deconstruct 10,000 years of metaphysical guilt (Original Sin, 1 Enoch 69, and philosophical pessimism) as visceral neuroinflammatory alarms mistaken for cosmic truths.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Filip Roth (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: