Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Demand-response (DR) evaluation depends on the observation window, but thermostat labels may not identify complete dispatch boundaries. We examined how active-label and fixed-duration windows affect cooling-runtime response estimates, uncertainty-qualified categories, and descriptive household comparisons in cleaned 2017 ecobee data. Three past-only baselines were evaluated using a forward calendar split. Among 175 common September onsets from 59 homes, the matched mean response was 62.72 s per five-minute step lower in the four-hour than in the active-label window (approximate household-by-date 95% interval for the difference: [−99.57,−29.29]). Across models, 30.3–45.1% of onsets changed category, predominantly becoming unresolved rather than reversing a resolved sign. Upper-quarter household membership also changed across windows, including in a balanced repeat-home analysis. Non-DR references and split-half checks qualify these exploratory comparisons. Uncertain dispatch ends and zero-fill ambiguity preclude causal interpretation. The findings support explicit reporting of window definitions and conclusion stability, without validating household targeting, override attribution, or measured energy savings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: