Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study compares a rate-independent cohesive-zone model with logarithmic, exponential, and power rate-dependent formulations for low-velocity impact of a fully clamped cross-ply carbonfibre-reinforced polymer laminate. Three-dimensional Abaqus/Explicit models combined a progressive intralaminar damage formulation with cohesive elements at seven ply interfaces. Predictions at 11.03 and 14.70 J were evaluated against published experimental force-time, forcedisplacement, absorbed-energy, and delamination data using global response metrics, ply-wise matrix damage, interface-wise delamination, and projected delamination morphology. At 11.03 J, the rate-independent model produced the lowest global mean absolute percentage error (MAPE; 5.05%), closely followed by the exponential model (5.57%). At 14.70 J, the exponential formulation was most accurate globally (2.41% MAPE), whereas the rate-independent formulation best predicted the projected delamination area under both conditions (+21.5% and -5.0%). The logarithmic formulation produced an unusually extensive matrix-damage field at 14.70 J despite moderate agreement in global metrics. Across the two conditions, the exponential model gave the lowest pooled global MAPE (3.99%), but no formulation was uniformly best for both global and local responses. Cohesive-model selection should therefore jointly consider structural response and local damage; conclusions about broader energy dependence require validation over a wider range of independently varied impact conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
ALI et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: