Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Contemporary schooling is increasingly charged with cultivating wellbeing, citizenship, resilience, and moral responsibility, yet questions of suffering, meaning, hope, and flourishing remain difficult to articulate within the dominant languages of secular pedagogy. In Hong Kong, a common state-sponsored social education subject shares a timetable with church-sponsored religious education. Revisiting Bernstein and Wexler, this article compares junior secondary curriculum materials for Citizenship, Economics and Society (CES) and Anglican Religious Education (RE). We argue that the two subjects rest on different principles of recontextualisation, and with them, different pedagogic discourses and anthropologies. CES recontextualises psychology, sociology, and financial literacy through the languages of self-management, responsibility, and adaptation. Anglican RE draws on much the same disciplinary knowledge but relates it to dignity, desire, neighbourliness, vocation, and hope. Shared concerns such as identity, consumption, and life purpose are organised through different codes of meaning, each making some questions thinkable and leaving others aside. Our purpose is analytic: we do not claim that either curriculum is superior. We suggest instead that theology in Anglican RE works less as subject content than as a meta-discourse through which existential questions become educationally intelligible, pointing to an existential dimension of powerful knowledge still undeveloped in curriculum debates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kwok et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: