Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
OBJECTIVE: Simulation-based training can be used to develop basic laparoscopic skills. Proficiency-based training is the gold standard but requires competency assessment. This study investigated validity evidence for a virtual reality simulator-based test assessing laparoscopic canine ovariectomy skills. STUDY DESIGN: Validity investigation study. SAMPLE POPULATION: Eleven surgeons with experience of at least 30 laparoscopic canine ovariectomies, and 16 novices with no laparoscopic experience. METHODS: Participants completed three attempts on both the left and right sides of the LapSim Canine Ovariectomy simulator module. Data were collected automatically, and the second and third attempts were analyzed. Discriminatory parameters were identified, and pass/fail levels were determined using the contrasting groups method. A noncompensatory standard-setting method was used. Validity evidence was reported using Messick's framework. RESULTS: Experienced surgeons were faster (total time, p = .008) and used fewer instrument movements than novices (combined instrument path length, p = .031; combined instrument angular path, p = .038). A test was developed for the module's left side and relevant pass/fail levels identified. Approximately half of the novices and one experienced surgeon failed the test. Test-retest analysis indicated generally low reliability. CONCLUSION: This study provided validity evidence for a virtual reality simulator-based test assessing competency in laparoscopic canine ovariectomy. The test can currently be used for formative assessment during training. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Virtual reality simulation is an emerging field in veterinary medicine with the potential to enhance surgical training. These findings can inform the incorporation of proficiency-based virtual reality training into veterinary curricula.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Redander et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: