Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Why do magmas with the same gas fraction differ in their ability to reach a fragmentation threshold? We integrate phase inventories over a conduit segment and close the volume balance with differential storage and distinct hydraulic and mechanical pressure loads. Given a source, conductances, boundary pressures and a scalar resistance, the model predicts retained pressure and, under constant conditions, whether and when the resistance is reached. At fixed gas fraction and resistance, a constructed segment with slow escape and mechanical relaxation reaches the threshold after 338 s. With rapid escape and relaxation, the pressure stays below the same threshold. For the tested geometries and forcing histories, a homogenisation-to-leakage time ratio of at most 0.1 kept the relative root-mean-square error in the mean-pressure history below 9%. Local bubble-wall stress was not calculated. A separate comparison uses 61 shock-tube thresholds. For 56 juvenile pumices, the Mueller criterion gives a lower mean absolute error than the Koyaguchi criterion (1.95 versus 2.90 MPa). Removing only the permeability term within Mueller’s law raises the error to 2.63 MPa, but the paired bootstrap interval for that change includes zero. The model predicts conditional pressure and threshold crossing, not eruptive style.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sebastiano Ettore Spoto (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: