Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The June 2025 revocation of four Mining Business Permits (IUPs) in Raja Ampat, Indonesia, underscores a fundamental tension between environmental protection and administrative legality. This article examines how Indonesian law constructs the authority to revoke mining permits on ecological grounds, evaluates whether the Raja Ampat revocations satisfy the requirements of authority, procedure, substance, and the General Principles of Good Administration (AUPB), and explores how Indian Supreme Court jurisprudence can inform a more robust standard for ecological revocation. Employing doctrinal legal research through statutory, case, conceptual, and comparative approaches, this study analyzes Indonesian mining, environmental, coastal and small-island, and administrative laws alongside selected Indian judicial decisions. It finds that ecological considerations do not constitute an autonomous ground for IUP revocation under Indonesian law; rather, environmental facts must be linked to identifiable obligations, established violations, and an explicit statutory basis—principally Article 119(a) of the Mining Law. While the public record indicates a compelling ecological rationale for the Raja Ampat revocations, the four permits occupied materially distinct legal and operational positions. Moreover, the competent revoking authority remains blurred between the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources and investment authorities, and the non-disclosure of the revocation instruments precludes verification of jurisdictional competence, procedural compliance, and individualized justification. Drawing on Indian jurisprudence concerning the public trust doctrine, differentiated remedies, remedial consequences, and legitimate expectations, this article proposes a "chain of legality," a seven-element standard for ecological revocation, and five regulatory reforms to coherently link ecological evidence, legal obligations, established violations, statutory grounds, and legal consequences.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maharani et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: