Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Using the 2024 Financial Planning Longitudinal Study (FPLS24), this study explores differences among respondents in their perceptions of services received from financial professionals by type of professional. Specifically, we explore differences between CFP® advised and non-CFP® advised households in their perceptions of (1) the breadth of service and (2) the extent to which the advisor is responsible for implementing plan recommendations. For both the breadth of service and implementation responsibility, the number of planning areas and differences within each planning area (i.e., estate planning, investment planning, psychology of financial planning, retirement planning, risk management and insurance planning, and tax planning) are examined. After controlling for relevant household characteristics, the results indicate that CFP® advised respondents tend to report more detailed service overall and within each planning area compared to non-CFP® advised households. Furthermore, CFP® advised respondents tend to report lower implementation responsibility. This study moves beyond the binary "advised versus unadvised" measure common in prior research to examine breadth of service and implementation responsibility as two dimensions of professional value that have not previously been studied together. Theoretically, it extends the financial help-seeking framework beyond the question of whether households seek help to the structure of the help they receive. For financial planning practice, the findings provide evidence that the CFP® credential is associated with broader and more fully delegated engagements. More broadly, because these dimensions differ systematically by type of professional, treating all advised households as equivalent can obscure the services being delivered, suggesting that assessments of the value of financial advice should compare like engagements rather than pooling advised and unadvised households.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Collins et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: