Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
One of the enduring challenges in the study of genocide is how to understand “in part” intentional group destruction. For some, operating in a political violence framework that distinguishes the underlying logic of genocide as the terminal destruction of a group rather than coercive control of the group, genocide in-part would seem contradictory. For others, operating in a legal framework, the law provides a threshold that only requires that a “substantial part” of a protected group be targeted for destruction. These different frameworks lead to disparate and contested labelling of cases, an endemic problem for Genocide Studies. This paper advances the concept of “dual-logic genocides” to help reconcile the differences. Dual-logic genocides are a type of partial group destruction in which perpetrators seek to destroy part of a group while simultaneously ignoring or permitting significant numbers of the same group to survive. In such cases, perpetrating organizations intend to continue exercising control over the surviving population and, in some cases, to use the genocidal violence to induce compliance with some behavioural outcome or political objective. The paper develops these claims from a social scientific analysis of the political violence literature and a doctrinal analysis of recent genocide jurisprudence. The paper further surveys examples from historical and contemporary cases, and distinguishes between identity and location-based, partial-group targeting.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ghaly et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: