Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Constitutional transitions involve not only the transfer of political sovereignty but also contestation over the meanings of political concepts. This article examines how presuppositional ambiguity contributed to competing interpretations of Hong Kong’s constitutional development during and after the Sino-British transition. Drawing on critical discourse historiography (CDH), the study analyses three key expressions: “constituted by elections” in the Sino-British Joint Declaration, “ultimate aim” in relation to universal suffrage under the Basic Law, and “love the country and love Hong Kong” in post-handover political discourse. The analysis demonstrates that these expressions contained unstated assumptions regarding electoral legitimacy, constitutional authority, national identity, and political loyalty. While British interpretations were informed by liberal-democratic understandings of electoral representation and institutional development, Chinese interpretations reflected a different political framework in which sovereignty, constitutional order, and patriotism were understood through state authority. These competing presuppositions transformed apparently shared constitutional language into sites of political contestation. The article further argues that such linguistic contestations have material consequences. Through subsequent political and educational developments, including electoral reforms and citizenship education frameworks, the meanings of political belonging and legitimate participation were progressively redefined. By examining Hong Kong as a postcolonial case of contested interpretive authority, this study demonstrates how language functions as a mechanism through which sovereignty, identity, and political legitimacy are constructed and negotiated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ka Hang Wong (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: