Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Formal ergotropy assumes unrestricted unitary control and can overstate the work available under constrained extraction. We compare it with the established optimum over all single-mode Gaussian unitaries in a coherently driven nonlinear optomechanical quantum battery. Both benchmarks use the same mechanical states and the same interaction-removal energy under an adopted sudden switch-off protocol. At the original 100- and 150-period states, corrected formal ergotropy is positive while corrected Gaussian-accessible work is negative. The small Gaussian-accessible work is associated with small displacement and nearly isotropic covariance, while the number-dephased diagnostic states retain almost all of the formal ergotropy at these times. We extend the comparison over 0--150 mechanical periods, sample five couplings and five detunings at a fixed time, and check a jointly enlarged cutoff. These finite samples do not establish continuous persistence or universal parameter robustness. The sign comparison is conditional on the adopted optical-loss model and sudden interaction removal; it excludes extraction-control costs and a complete charging--extraction work balance. At 100 mechanical periods, the corrected-work sign discrepancy is resolved at all five sampled couplings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: