Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Modifiers can improve the 28-day strength of high-volume fly ash (HVFA) concrete, but additional materials and processing may offset the environmental and economic benefits of cement replacement. This study assembled a harmonised literature database of 62 formulations, comprising 50 single-modifier HVFA mixtures, seven combined-modifier mixtures and five ordinary Portland cement (OPC) references. A consistent cradle-to-gate environmental and production-cost framework used 1 m³ of concrete as the principal functional unit, supplemented by GWP and cost per unit of 28-day mean cylinder-equivalent compressive strength. The assessment combined strength screening, strength–GWP–cost Pareto analysis, complementary performance-normalised indicators, OPC safeguards across 12 non-GWP categories and TOPSIS ranking under four weighting scenarios. Technical screening at ≥ 32 MPa retained 29 modified formulations, eight of which were principal Pareto-efficient. The leading slag-modified formulation achieved 55.0 MPa at 292.29 kg CO₂-eq/m³ and A$271.19/m³, with lower impacts than OPC50 in all 12 non-GWP categories. The leading silica-fume formulation achieved 60.3 MPa and the lowest strength-normalised GWP and cost, at 5.15 kg CO₂-eq/(m³·MPa) and A$4.86/(m³·MPa). A hydrated-lime formulation recorded the lowest GWP among baseline-eligible formulations, at 221.92 kg CO₂-eq/m³. At the baseline ≥ 32 MPa threshold, the silica-fume formulation led TOPSIS under balanced and strength-priority weighting, whereas the slag-modified formulation led under environmental- and cost-priority weighting. Both retained the leading two positions across all tested strength thresholds and weighting scenarios. The findings support formulation-specific selection according to performance requirements and priorities. Structural suitability and whole-life performance require project-specific design and durability verification.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patrisia et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: