Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This study develops an operational, evidence-graded supply-chain readiness framework (E-SCRL) that separates capability maturity, lifecycle state and evidential sufficiency in process-innovation decisions. Design/methodology/approach The study adopts a structured integrative evidence-mapping and methodological framework-development approach. An analysis of 44 studies informs the identification of seven supply-chain readiness domains and the development of the E-SCRL assessment framework. The proposed instrument integrates cumulative maturity requirements (M0–M4), independent lifecycle classifications (observed, reconstructed and projected), ordinal evidence grades (E0–E3), and a threshold-based evidence-coverage profile. Non-compensatory assessment criteria and state-specific decision rules are examined through logical consistency tests and applied to two process-innovation contexts, addressing projected modelling readiness and reconstructed operational practices. Findings Maturity research covers operational integration, digitalisation, performance, sustainability and resilience, but the reviewed reporting fields do not consistently identify whether a score is observed, reconstructed or projected. E-SCRL prevents lifecycle state from being confused with insufficient evidence and prevents strong evidence for a model from being interpreted as evidence of implementation. Research limitations/implications The evidence map is not a multi-database full-text systematic review, and the governance thresholds require field calibration and inter-rater testing. Practical implications The instrument supplies reproducible requirements, evidence thresholds, permissible wording and next actions for operational improvement and capital-design gates. Originality/value E-SCRL converts a maturity score into a governed claim: a domain profile, lifecycle state, evidence-coverage vector and sufficiency flag. It therefore supports ex post and ex ante assessment without treating them as evidentially equivalent.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Santos et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: