Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Extreme precipitation represents a key expression of hydroclimatic variability, particularly in regions characterised by strong topographic gradients and complex atmospheric forcing. This study intercompares CHIRPS, ERA5, ERA5-Land, AgERA5, and PERSIANN-CDR across Rio de Janeiro State during 1983–2024, using the Brazilian Daily Weather Gridded Data (BR-DWGD) as a common gauge-interpolated comparator rather than an independent observational benchmark. Five ETCCDI indices, PRCPTOT, RX1Day, RX5Day, R95p, and CDD, were calculated at annual and seasonal scales and assessed primarily using Percent Bias (PBIAS) and Willmott’s index of agreement ( d ). CHIRPS generally showed the closest agreement with BR-DWGD for PRCPTOT, RX1Day, and RX5Day, whereas the ERA5-family products showed comparatively stronger correspondence for CDD and selected extreme-precipitation indices during JJA. PERSIANN-CDR exhibited larger departures for several combinations of indices, seasons, and regions. No product showed the closest agreement for every index and season, and substantial spatial biases preclude interpreting comparatively high agreement as uniformly low bias. Because BR-DWGD is derived from interpolated rain-gauge records and CHIRPS also incorporates gauge information, their station inputs cannot be assumed to be independent; their correspondence may partly reflect shared gauge records and does not constitute independent validation. The findings therefore support index- and scale-specific product selection, conditional on the comparator, metrics, potential gauge dependence, and spatial harmonisation procedure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Terassi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: