Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Models of the end-state of black holes typically face a fundamental dilemma: either accepting an exceedingly slow Hawking evaporation that terminates in dilute radiation, or positing that black hole cores spawn causally disconnected spacetime regions (baby universes), thereby draining energy from the observable universe. Black-to-white hole bounce models [3–5] open a third possibility within a single universe, yet they predominantly consider isolated black holes. This paper poses an unexplored question: can a black hole continuously accreting over cosmological epochs terminate via horizon cessation, and does accretion act as a trigger, a delay mechanism, or an irrelevant factor? We do not propose a complete physical model. Instead, we organize the problem within Lakatos’s methodology of scientific research programmes, establishing a hard core of three commitments (causal closure, replacement of the classical singularity by a bounded-density quantum gravity regime, and horizon termination returning energy to the same spacetime) alongside a protective belt of replaceable auxiliary hypotheses. We evaluate candidate trigger variables and construct a system of overlapping constraints comprising the Generalized Second Law (GSL), time–bandwidth limits, the Eardley instability, baryon number conservation, the Null Energy Condition (NEC), and the Dyson luminosity bound. Based on existing literature, we find no candidate variable whereby accretion triggers the transition, and there are grounds to suspect that accretion merely delays it (given that bounce timescales grow as M² within the Planck star framework). Furthermore, the GSL combined with wavelength-scale constraints forces the bulk of the emitted energy into extremely dilute radiation, rendering the “matter regeneration” claim difficult to sustain, even though the “energy return” commitment may remain viable. We specify falsification criteria alongside indicators of programme progression or degeneration, and outline three closed mathematical problems for subsequent investigation. The contribution of this work lies in pinpointing precisely where the theoretical difficulties reside, rather than claiming to resolve them.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thanh Tuyên Nguyễn (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: