Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Justifying parental authority is a problem for libertarian theory. Paternalism appears incompatible with self-ownership, yet parenting requires paternalistic control. This seems to present a dilemma: either deny the legitimacy of parental authority or deny that children are self-owners. This article first reconstructs the schools of thought that have grasped each horn. The equal-freedom school denies parental authority, and the homesteading school makes the parental role a property right. The article shows that both schools fail because of the same mistaken assumption that libertarianism denies enforceable parental obligations. It then extends the theory of causal parental responsibility from obligation to authority. Because parents voluntarily create a foreseeable state of peril, they incur a tort obligation to guide the child safely to independent adulthood. Limited parental authority is therefore not a property right but a derivative power, instrumentally necessary to discharge preexisting obligations owed to the child as a self-owner. This theory explains the origin, exclusivity, jointness, limits, and termination of parental authority and identifies it as an instance of a previously undistinguished category: derivative instrumental authority.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jake Desyllas (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: