Key result
Transcatheter device closure linked to an absolute ~8% reduction in complications causing delayed discharge vs. surgery.
Why the study?
Concern surrounded abandoning conventional midline sternotomy for secundum ASD closure in children in favor of percutaneous interventional or minimally invasive surgical approaches aimed at better cosmetic results and resource utilization.
Does percutaneous interventional or minimally invasive surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defect improve clinical outcomes, hospital stay, and costs compared with conventional midline sternotomy in children?
Cohort (n=171)
Does percutaneous interventional or minimally invasive surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defect improve clinical outcomes, hospital stay, and costs compared with conventional midline sternotomy in children?
Percutaneous and minimally invasive surgical ASD closures in children are equally effective as conventional sternotomy with shorter hospital stays and lower costs, though transcatheter closure had the lowest complication rate.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports feasibility of less invasive pediatric ASD repair; randomized trials needed before practice change.
Objectives The goal of this study was to evaluate percutaneous interventional and minimally invasive surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defect (ASD) in children. Background Concern has surrounded abandoning conventional midline sternotomy in favor of the less invasive approaches pursuing a better cosmetic result and a more rational resource utilization. Methods A retrospective analysis was performed on the patients treated from June 1996 to December 1998. Results One hundred seventy-one children (median age 5.8 years, median weight 22.1 kg) underwent 52 device implants, 72 minimally invasive surgical operations and 50 conventional sternotomy operations. There were no deaths and no residual left to right shunt in any of the groups. The overall complication rate causing delayed discharge was 12.6% for minimally invasive surgery, 12.0% for midline sternotomy and 3.8% for transcatheter device closure (p < 0.01). The mean hospital stay was 2.8 +/- 1.0 days, 6.5 +/- 2.1 days and 2.1 +/- 0.5 days (p < 0.01); the skin-to-skin time was 196 +/- 43 min, 163 +/- 46 min and 118 +/- 58 min, respectively (p < 0.001). Extracorporeal circulation time was 49.9 +/- 10.1 min in the minithoracotomy group versus 37.2 +/- 13.8 min in the sternotomy group (p < 0.01) but without differences in aortic cross-clamping time. Sternotomy was the most expensive procedure (15,000 EUR +/- 1,050 EUR vs. 12,250 EUR +/- 472 EUR for minithoracotomy and 13,000 EUR +/- 300 EUR for percutaneous devices). Conclusions While equally effective compared with sternotomy, the cosmetic and financial appeal of the percutaneous and minimally invasive approaches must be weighed against their greater exposure to technical pitfalls. Adequate training is needed if a strategy of surgical or percutaneous minimally invasive closure of ASD in children is planned in place of conventional surgery.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Formigari et al. (2001) conducted a cohort in Secundum atrial septal defect (ASD) (n=171). Percutaneous interventional device closure or minimally invasive surgical closure (minithoracotomy) vs. Conventional midline sternotomy was evaluated on Overall complication rate causing delayed discharge (p=<0.01). Transcatheter device closure had a lower complication rate causing delayed discharge than minimally invasive surgery and sternotomy, with 0% mortality in all groups.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: