Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article aims to examine and provide a framework to approach the justification of ethics education (EE). By ‘EE’, we mean the diverse practices that are explicitly concerned with and aimed at the ethical dimension of education in one way or another—including the fields of character education, moral education, and values education. In this regard, we show that the currently dominant justification of EE is based on posited ethical ‘needs’ that instrumentalize education. We argue that this is insufficient from an educational–theoretical perspective and suggest an alternative justification that foregrounds the ethical possibilities that EE could generate and mediate. The article proceeds in four sections. First, we present the importance of the question of justification in educational thought by evaluating what is ‘educational’ about education. Then, we draw on Masschelein and Simon’s work on ‘external’ and ‘internal’ perspectives on school education and elaborate them as distinct forms of justification—an external one, which imposes predeterminations on education, and an internal one, which focuses on the possibilities generated by education. In the third section, we apply this framework to EE and explain how it performs a destabilization of what we consider to be ethical. In the fourth section, we further sketch the external and internal perspectives by examining two examples of EE and show that an appropriate assessment of the value of these practices requires that the prevalent, external justification be supplemented with the emergent, internal one.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Torres et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: