Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Betrayal is conventionally theorized as a breach of trust and a violation of expectation. Such accounts leave unexplained why explanation so rarely restores the betrayed subject, and why interrogating the betrayer tends to intensify the rupture rather than close it. This clinical-conceptual focus paper explores betrayal via a clinical case using semiotic theory. In this paper, betrayal is reconceptualized as a rupture between lived experience and the concepts through which selfhood and relational continuity have been organized. The betrayed subject seeks to reestablish coherence through signifiers that betrayal has rendered unreliable. The case shows a paradox: the structural impossibility of restoring through questioning a shared reality whose coherence depended on remaining unquestioned. The apparatus of repair is contaminated by what it would repair. The clinical case illustrates three stages of aftermath through which the interrogation of the other gradually turns inward, and the body becomes the final surface of self-interrogation. Read this way, betrayal is not only an interpersonal injury but a crisis of signification. It disrupts the subject’s capacity to locate themselves within their own narrative and reframes post-betrayal doubt, the limits of factual reconstruction, and the body’s emergence as a last site of meaning when symbolic coherence fails.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lía A. Roth (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: